Is it lawful? The Growing Use of Gaming and Betting in India
Introduction
Betting and gaming have shaped Indian society for thousands of years stemming from old customs and modern entertainment. People have loved games of chance and skill for ages, from ancient dice games in the Mahabharata to today’s booming online gaming world. Yet, this widespread interest clashes with a mix of legal limits moral debates, and social views. In India, a mix of old British laws and state-specific rules govern gambling leading to a patchwork of regulations across the country. Some states like Goa and Sikkim have set up regulated gambling sectors, while others have banned betting outright worried about addiction and harm to society. The rise of the internet has made things even trickier, as online platforms for fantasy sports, poker, and rummy thrive in legal gray areas. , court decisions and scandals, like the IPL spot-fixing mess, have shown we need one set of rules that balances control with new ideas. As India’s gaming world grows, everyone involved needs to tackle big questions about what’s legal, fair, and how to play .
This blog explores the legal framework, cultural significance, and future prospects of the expanding but controversial betting and gaming industry in India.
History of gambling in India
Betting had deep roots in ancient Indian society and myths. People played dice games (aksha) in epic stories like the Mahabharata, which served as both fun and warnings about risks. Many traditional sports and pastimes such as wrestling, cockfighting, and archery involved betting. This practice often became part of local celebrations. The British brought in rules to limit gambling when they ruled India. In 1867, the Public Gambling Act was passed. This law banned most public betting but allowed some activities like horse racing, which it saw as “games of skill.” This created the first legal divide between games of chance and skill, an idea that still shapes India’s gaming laws today. After India gained independence, betting took place in unofficial sectors, though lotteries and horse racing kept their legal status. But the digital boom in the 2000s led to a big change. Because the laws were unclear, online games like rummy, poker, and fantasy sports gained popularity. Skill-based gaming was pioneered by companies like Dream11 and MPL, while the growing link between sports and gambling was demonstrated by IPL betting and scandals. Tonight marks the climax of a momentous period in Indian betting. New regulations are required due to the quick growth of internet gambling and technological developments like blockchain, which increases betting transparency. The development of gambling games in India is not just a story of enjoyment; it is also a story of technological disruption, societal change, and legal issues.
Navigating the legal framework in India
The gambling laws in India have evolved from the Public Gambling Act of 1867, which was the former legislation under which it was prohibited to manage or visit any public gambling houses. However, because it focuses on physical facilities and excludes online gaming and betting, this Act has a narrow scope. Crucially, the Indian Constitution leaves gambling laws to individual states, which creates great regional variation. Casinos and other forms of gaming are legal and regulated in Goa, Sikkim, and Daman, while states like Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, and Kerala have banned gaming and betting, although courts regularly reverse such bans due to constitutional problems. One of the main differences in Indian gambling laws is the distinction between games of skill and games of chance
The challenges of online betting and gaming
In fact, the gambling industry has seen great changes during the digital age. The web and better mobile tech have opened up new ways to gamble through online betting sites and digital games. Online casinos, poker games, sports betting sites, and fantasy sports leagues are now common drawing millions of users in India. The Public Gaming Act of 1867 is not applicable when it comes to modern online gaming. The law came out long before anyone thought of the internet and digital gaming, so it’s old and doesn’t work well to control today’s gambling. The lack of clear rules for online gaming sites creates a legal gap that both gamblers and operators often find confusing.
State Level Regulations
The part that state governments play in controlling gaming is another important consideration. Although Indian states are free to enact their own gaming laws, the Public Gaming Act of 1867 is a federal law. This has resulted in a disjointed strategy for national regulation of online gambling and gaming. While some governments have completely banned online betting services, others, like Sikkim and Goa, have made significant strides in regulating online casinos and gambling through licensing schemes. Because something that is legal in one state might be considered illegal in another, this patchwork regulatory framework causes confusion for both operators and users. The Public Gambling Act of 1867 has been proposed to be changed to allow for new forms of gaming and gambling. Legal professionals and industry participants argue that the Act should be changed to take into account the growth of esport, online gaming, and other digital entertainment. A new law or an amended version of the current Act may provide precise guidelines for what online gaming and betting are prohibited, create a regulatory body to oversee operations, and protect users from dishonest platforms. India’s gaming regulations could be changed with significant economic benefits. Legalizing and controlling online gambling could boost the technology and entertainment industries, generate revenue for the government, and create jobs. However, the possible advantages of a regulated online gambling industry would have to be weighed against public welfare concerns.
Some famous case related to betting in India
In India, online gambling has become very popular, but it has also been the subject of scandals, court cases, and notorious cases.
Bombay High Court:- Fantasy sports gaming is not gambling (Dream 11 PIL)
Whether fantasy sports are a game of skill or betting lies at the heart of the Dream11 case. Best fantasy sports website in India, Dream11 allows you to manage a virtual team and win prizes based on a real player performance. Critics say it is online betting, while believers consider it a game of skill incorporating strategic decision-making and sports wisdom. The battle really registered when states — some like Andhra Pradesh, Telangana and Tamil Nadu — banned these under anti-gambling laws. But then, the Supreme Court along with the high courts of Rajasthan and Bombay made a statement that fantasy games under Dream11 were primarily skill-based and not gambling-related. Tax fraud concerns the GST Council on contesting the applicability of gaming laws on Dream11. The company reiterates that it complies with the statutes of the land and views itself as a legitimate business under Indian law. This case has brought forth the problems associated with the regulatory framework of India in a rapidly evolving online gaming market.
Amit M Nair vs State of Gujarat (2020)
Amit Nair is the petitioner in Amit M. Nair versus State of Gujarat; he was charged with participating in illegal online betting through a betting syndicate operating in Gujarat, where gambling is specifically prohibited under the Gujarat Prevention of Gambling Act. The main question was if internet betting, especially with respect to cricket and other sports, came under the gambling laws enacted by the state. The petitioner argued that online betting and fantasy sports are usually perceived as skill-based games; they are not gambling and hence the state’s prohibition is excessive since these platforms generally operate out of state borders. However, the state contended that since gambling in all its forms including online gambling should be made illegal under the Gujarat Act and Public Gambling Act of 1867. The court ruled in concern to that of state and upheld the illegality, viewing it under the provisions of Gujarati law and emphasizing the application of state gaming regulations to online platforms.
All India Gaming Federation (AIGF) vs State Of Tamil Nadu
The All India Gaming Federation (AIGF) opposed the amendment to the Tamil Nadu Gaming and Police Laws (Amendment) Act, 2021, which prohibited gambling on the Internet, including online rummy and fantasy sports, in the case of All India Gaming Federation vs. State of Tamil Nadu. The argument of AIGF was that since skill-based games such as fantasy sports are not termed as gambling, they should not be banned under state laws. The petitioners claimed such prohibition violated Article 19(1)(g) of the Indian Constitution, which conferred upon every citizen the right to trade and business. The state contended that this law was intended to save the public from the adverse effects of online gambling, like becoming addicted and losing cash, and that the state had the right to manage such activities within its precincts. The Madras High Court, having halted the law’s execution temporarily for further discussion, brought to light the tension that exists between state laws and the legality of skill-based gambling in India.
Pauly Vadakkan vs State Of Kerala (2021)
The applicant in the case of Pauly Vadakkan vs. State of Kerala was Pauly Vadakkan, popularly known for illegal betting across Kerala in activities, especially with regard to cricket events. All forms of gambling—even sports betting, for that matter—were banned under the Kerala Gaming Act. Vadakkan disputed the claims, arguing that these under state law did not constitute illegal gambling activities but online fantasy sports and skill-based games like fantasy cricket. He stated that these are entirely different from games of chance and prizewinning games as they involve a higher degree of skill and strategy. However, the state’s contention being otherwise, according to the provisions of the Kerala Gaming Act along with the Public Gambling Act of 1867, any betting on sports-is considered as illegal gambling and, hence, brought down the online betting practices. Thus, the court unanimously decided in favor of the state, saying that even skill-based games in this context were illegal gambling in Kerala.
Mahadev Betting Scam
The cricket and other online games betting platform is probably the most useful among the Mahadev Book software. India is the nation where most users enjoy this software and most people love it by placing bets in billions on sports, especially cricket. During raids by the Gujarat police and most of the law enforcement agencies in India, some of the major network operators were arrested. All the accused have now been prosecuted under the Public Gambling Act, 1867, and the Information Technology Act since the operation of this platform was totally illegal through web and mobile applications. In a number of judgments, Madhya Pradesh High Court and some other courts have shown that online betting sites, especially those having skill-based games like fantasy sports, tend to be illegal as long as wagering is based upon an uncertain outcome. The judgments have upheld the power of the state to legislate and penalize online gambling under the existing gambling laws.
Conclusion
The growing gaming and gambling industry in India adds to an increasingly complex system of law. There are many arguments and debates on how to differentiate games of skill from games of chance as a large boom industry, created by the rise in online gaming platforms especially fantasy sports, has shown its face; however, legal issues on this front are serious. The states have drafted various laws; some take a progressive outlook while the others fall under stiff prohibition, especially concerning online gambling and gaming. While the two key legal documents in the area include the Public Gambling Act of 1867 and the Indian Penal Code (IPC), their applicability gets hampered due to the absence of clearly defined, uniform laws concerning online games. Judiciaries have majorly grappled with regulating companies’ affairs within a business-friendly framework, considering the increased participation of various international platforms.
Author: Aditya Gautam, in case of any queries please contact/write back to us at support@ipandlegalfilings.com or IP & Legal Filing
References
- Las Vegas US Rep. Titus in a Dead Heat for Re-Election, Survey Says. https://www.casino.org/news/las-vegas-us-rep-dina-titus-in-a-dead-heat-for-re-election-survey-says/
- https://www.barandbench.com/columns/the-roaring-success-of-online-gaming-industry-should-create-an-urgency-to-protect-indian-innovations-and-ips
- https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/money-laundering-a-major-threat-to-indian-online-gaming-sector-says-dif-report/article68791824.ece
- https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/chhattisgarh/mahadev-app-betting-case-enforcement-directorate-attaches-fresh-assets-worth-388-crore/article68958190.ece
- https://www.barandbench.com/news/madras-high-court-upholds-tn-online-gaming-act-cannot-apply-rummy-poker-other-games-skill
- https://www.livelaw.in/news-updates/kerala-high-court-notice-virat-kohli-tamanna-bhatia-aju-varghese-ban-online-gambling-168993
- https://www.khaitanco.com/thought-leaderships/After-Madras-HC-Gujarat-HC-draws-attention-of-the-state-government-to-online-gambling-and-the-need-to-regulate-them-in-larger-public-interest
- https://www.livelaw.in/law-firms/law-firm-articles-/betting-gambling-public-gambling-act-kyc-information-technology-act-asia-cup-cricket-tournament-singhania-and-partners-llp-236614
- https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/supreme-court-transfers-to-itself-all-petitions-pending-in-high-courts-challenging-gst-on-online-gaming-254339
- https://www.barandbench.com/news/pil-bombay-high-court-ban-gambling-apps-junglee-rummy-rummy-circle
